I Play Rocky

Because Rocky is now viewed as a classic, it’s easy to forget how shocking it was when the movie beat out All the President’s Men, Network, and Taxi Driver as Best Picture at the 49th Academy Awards. The boxing drama was a total underdog, just like its main character. Peter Farrelly’s I Play Rocky tells the story of how the film improbably made its way to the screen. Even if you don’t like Rocky, the true tale is sufficiently amazing to keep you in rapt attention.

Relative newcomer Anthony Ippolito delivers a star-making performance as an aspiring young actor named Sylvester Stallone. Having trouble landing meaningful roles, he is encouraged by girlfriend Sasha (AnnaSophia Robb) to write a screenplay and give himself the best part. Several scripts later, he comes up with a special one about a fighter named Rocky Balboa. It gets the attention of Hollywood producers Robert Chartoff (Toby Kebbell) and Irwin Winkler (PJ Byrne), who offer to turn it into a motion picture. But Stallone insists that the only way he’ll sell the script is if he gets to play the title character. That leads to a situation where the studio imposes a series of rules seemingly designed to make Stallone fail so they can cast a “real actor” instead.

The heart of I Play Rocky is that Stallone’s script is extremely personal, leading him to foil every effort to make the movie without his participation. Much humor is derived from the way he frustrates Chartoff and Winkler, as well as studio chief Sandy Mattox (Tracy Letts). Most aspiring actors or writers would jump at the chance to get a movie made, no matter what concessions they’d need to make. Not Sly. It’s a testament to the strength of his screenplay that nobody ever flat-out tells him to hit the road. Big laughs arise from Stallone’s hutzpah.

During the second half, we get to see how the filmmakers, including director John Avildsen (Jay Duplass), navigate those studio rules. This is where the movie gets really entertaining because everybody is scrambling to surmount a series of obstacles that threaten to derail the production at every turn. While filming the famous training sequence wherein Rocky punches giant slabs of meat, for example, Stallone hurts his hands on the rock-hard frozen beef. The solution? Keep hitting it anyway and worry about the severity of the injury later. Learning about all the problems faced along the way underlines how much Rocky and Rocky were kindred spirits.

With his distinct look and gravelly, mumbling speech patterns, Sylvester Stallone is not an easy person to portray. Ippolito resembles him here to a shocking degree. He also nails the voice. His efforts are much more than an imitation, though. While convincingly capturing Stallone’s persona, Ippolito simultaneously conveys the varying emotions underneath. You can feel Sly’s vulnerability as he struggles to prove his merits. Similarly, you feel his unwavering belief that he is the only person who can truly play Rocky Balboa. The strength and depth of his performance helps give the film a rousing, crowd-pleasing quality.

A top-notch supporting cast contributes to the effect. I Play Rocky takes you behind the scenes of a cinematic classic, providing insight into how, against all odds, it practically willed itself into existence. Yes, there are a few areas glossed over, and Farrelly (Green Book) occasionally goes for an easy laugh. Regardless, the film is hugely entertaining and certain to delight cinephiles of all stripes.


☆ ☆ ☆ out of four

I Play Rocky is rated PG-13 for strong language, brief sexual material, and smoking. The running time is 2 hours and 8 minutes.


© 2026 Mike McGranaghan